Archive for category Mainstream Media
By Alex Webb
Following the survey I launched yesterday, here is a bubble diagram of where people last commented on news. Most people who took part were journalism students and the sample was small, but it gives an interesting snapshop of how people comment online. I asked participants where they had commented on a news story in the past six months, if at all.
There’s a lot of scaremongering that goes on about user generated content replacing ‘real’ journalism. With so many people doing it for free, will we all be out of a job in a few years? cry frightened journalism students. Well no, because amateurs will never have the skills, training and resources of professionals, so they will never replace them. Kate Dubinski has written a brilliant post on the subject over at the London Free Press, and I couldn’t agree with her more.
“The stuff we’re paid to do is — in part because we’re paid to do it — as professional, accurate and removed of bias as we can possibly make it,” she argues.
“You pick up the paper, you read a story online, and you (should) know it’s been run through several filters before it got to you. Those filters have hopefully caught typos, glaring holes in logic, bias, and all the rest of the stuff that makes you “trust” us.’
But this is not to say that user generated content is not of terrific importance in modern news-gathering. Crucially, Dubinski adds that “citizen journalists become sources for professional journalists, not necessarily competition.”
And what sources they are. As this blog has previously noted, citizen journalists are the eyes on the ground as humanity suffers earthquakes, genocide, revolution, tsunami. They are the ones who catch the police out if they overstep the mark, and they are the ones who go where the mainstream media can’t. Their videos, tweets and testimonies are gold-dust to a professional journalist, providing detail, colour and expertise which could not come from anywhere else.
But UGC does far more than simply improve stories that old-school journalists would always have reported on anyway. In fact, certain ‘users’ create stories by the mere act of ‘generating content’. I am of course, talking about celebs. How often do you see a story which is based entirely on what some tabloid favorite has said on Twitter? Over at my beloved Mail Online today, you will see that the top story is ‘Katy Perry in Twitter Feud with Calvin Harris over tour‘. The journalist doesn’t even need to do any work; a quick look at Twitter sees the entire story unfolding neatly all by itself, unobstructed by secrecy or worse, PR.
Social media, crowd sourcing, citizen journalism, user generated content; all are undeniably amazing sources. Far from threatening professional journalists, UGC has made their life easier. Stories are there: created, or found, by someone else. Just as citizen journalists need the mainstream media to publicise their content if it is ever to reach the masses, so the mainstream media increasingly takes its stories from UGC. It’s a two-way relationship which is mutually beneficial.
But journalists must not let UGC make them lazy. Reporting on what a famous person says on Twitter is not particularly interesting; any readers who are interested in said celebrity probably follow them anyway, so reporting two hours later on a public online exchange is basically redundant. Quoting Twitter users, many hiding behind a veil of online anonymity, is no substitute to meeting real people and talking to them (Metro I’m looking at you.) As Dubinski says, journalists are the gatekeepers, and they must select, filter and give an intelligent platform to the UGC that really needs to be seen.
calvin harris, celebrities, celebrity, charlie sheen, citizen journalism, george michael, gossip, journalism, katy perry, London Free Press, Mail Online, social media, sources, twitter, user generated content
You are currently browsing the archives for the Mainstream Media category.
- RT @sonymusicuk: RT & follow for a chance to #WIN tickets to @MileyCyrus' #BangerzTour at the @Phones4uArena on May 14th! #WinMileyTix http… 3 years ago
- RT @syco: LADIES & GENTS…the time has come! @LittleMix give you the #SALUTEVIDEO! Watch: youtu.be/Kjpa0SMOug0 #PreOrderSalute http://t.co… 3 years ago
- RT @syco: Good luck to @onedirection's @Real_Liam_Payne, @Louis_Tomlinson, @zaynmalik, @Harry_Styles & @NiallOfficial who start #WWATour TO… 3 years ago
- RT @syco: It's Friday, it's Easter weekend and @onedirection's #YouAndIVideo is out today. Good things come in threes it seems! http://t.co… 3 years ago
- RT @SYCO_NEWS: If you haven't heard already (where have you been?) @onedirection's #YouAndI video is out in 3 days! Who's excited? http://t… 3 years ago
you generated content7/7 Afghanistan army Ashton Kutcher bbc Billy Carnegie blog cablegate celebrities censorship charing cross citizen citizen journalism CNN iReport comment communities community content dailymail Daily Telegraph debate Demotix Donald McMaster douglas rushkoff eastern europe Emily Bell generated gervais gossip Guardian harassment huffington post IED Iraq japan journalism legal libel london london underground Mail Online moderation money NBC news newspapers novinky online journalism participation Paul Bradshaw Peter McQuaid post power responsibility ricky gervais Royal Regiment of Scotland social media soldier telegraph tfl the times tsunami tube twitter ugc underground user user generated content video why wifi wikileaks writing for free yougeneration Youtube